Liquid Eyeliner

I’m honestly obsessed with this eyeliner. The tip is precise and smooth, so it’s easy to get a clean line even if you’re not great with liquid liners. It dries quickly and doesn’t smudge, flake, or transfer throughout the day, even after long hours. The color is a true black, not grayish or watery, and it gives that crisp look without feeling heavy. I’ve used it on both bare lids and over eyeshadow, and it holds up beautifully either way. Plus, it’s hypoallergenic, vegan, and cruelty-free, which I really appreciate. It’s long-lasting but still easy to remove at the end of the day with a gentle cleanser. This has definitely become one of my go-to eyeliners, reliable, clean, and looks great every time.

Pretty good. I wanted something gentle for sensitive eyes, and easy to apply and remove. This fits the bill. Doesn't bother my eyes at all. Matte after drying. It does seem to get in your eyes a lot during removal, but I'm not sure if that's normal for liquid eyeliner. VERY messy during removal/touch ups. I don't have oily skin or sweat much, but if you do, this one may not be for you. It comes away very easily with water or makeup remover and smears all over, so be aware of that. I haven't had any trouble with it coming off or smudging throughout the day, except in the lower outer corner as sometimes I have tearing there, not noticable, though.

This went on easy. Stayed on pretty much all day. I took it off with coconut oil, then soap and water. It did not irritate my eyes the first few times I used it but after several uses, I am getting a slight allergic reaction because ANY product you open and use repeatedly with the same applicator slowly collects bacteria.

I usually cannot wear eye makeup without it looking terrible just minutes after putting it on. This is because I live in the tropics. It is humid and hot year round here. On top of that, I have oily skin and hooded eyelids. So when I blink my eyes (with other brand eyeliners) you see an extra line on my lid where the lid touches itself. Throughout the day it gets more smudged and looks worse. By the end of the day, I look like a hot mess. HOWEVER, this eyeliner stays put and looks good after several hours out and about running errands in the heat. No extra line when my eyelids touch. No raccoon eyes. No smudge. A nice clean line that stays. I’m so glad I decided to give it a try. Also I like that it is NOT waterproof and comes off easily when I wash my face. Stays when I need it too, but easy to remove. I find that waterproof eyeliners smudge more, yet are harder to remove. So I stay away from them. This is perfect. If you look at the attached pictures. You can see when my eyes are open there is a hood and makeup tends to smudge. In the bottom picture where I’m looking down, you can see my entire eyelid and there is no smudge. This picture was taken 5 hours after applying it and after running errands in humid weather.

This product is ok. I bought it because I was looking for eyeliners with "clean" formulas that rated well on the Yuka app. The eyeliner looks good when first applied but doesn't last throughout the day. It is very easy to smudge, and if the smallest amount of water touches it, you look like a member of KISS with a huge smear across your face. The applicator tip can make it hard to apply the eyeliner where you want it (but that could also be some user error on my part). Over all the product is just ok. I did repurchase it because I haven't found a better alternative yet, but know you are buying mostly an applicator with a tiny amount of product.

My one, and only, eye liner. I’ve been using this eyeliner for years (guessing 5+ years) - it is perfect. It meets all of my eyeliner needs: •clean, safe ingredients - a must for my beauty products and especially for something next to your eye! •stays put all day. Like legit. (does not smear) •easy to apply (liquid and application tip are spot on for an easy application) •easy to fix an application error (wet a q-tip and run it along the line for an easy, effective clean up). •no odor. IYKYK. I’m allergic to fragrance & it is surprising how many makeup products have fragrance added to them! Not this one! I’ve used a ton of Honest brand products for over a decade now. Some are great, some are so/so. This eyeliner is perfection. I hope they never stop making it.

This is very messy eyeliner. I had to remove my eye makeup twice because I thought my mascara was running so I removed it first. I still had black on my lids and under my eye so I knew it was the liner. It burns as well. Do not recommend you purchase this

Love this one! Applies really good! And safe and non toxic! Great product!

Never used an eyeliner as terribly designed as this! It didn't stay on and smeared everywhere when I blinked in the day. Obviously this product can't even stand a bit of sweat or tears. I had to check on a mirror and wipe the smudges throughout the day. So I gave up on this and bought a new eyeliner from another brand. It wasted my money.

Love this stuff! Goes on smooth and lasts all day. Looks great! Overall a pretty clean product, ingredient wise. Will buy again and again!

I found it so hard to find non-toxic eye liners that didn't have a hard brush (making it hard to apply). This brush is has a smooth enough tip that it applies easily! Lasts all day :)

I like the fact that the product has natural ingredients and has a nice texture, It fell fine on my skin. But it was very dissapointing because it didn's last too much. I had tears in my eyes after walking with the wind, and when I saw myself in a mirror it was smudged on the sides of eyes. So, if you sweat or have tears in your eyes while using the eyeliner, you will look like a koala

Nice product