Nordic Ware 3-Piece Cookie Set, 1 Pack, with Aqua Baking Mat

Disappointed with quality control as the tray arrived with a dent.

Awesome product. Very good price, for the rack the pan and the silicon liner. Also love the color of the teal on it.

Soooo much better than my old ones which were warped, stained and nasty. These are much sturdier and seem to hold their shape a lot better. Still don't know what to do with the plastic mat, though.

Sheet pan is awesome. Bakes well- from cookies to veggies and meat. Easiest sheet pan to wash up after baking directly on pan that I have ever owned. Doesnt brown cookies as quickly but it is super shiny so maybe after some use it will brown more quickly. Not a big deal though, just takes a couple mins more cook time. Silicone lining works fine. Not the same quality as SilPat type but it gets the job done. Rack also is good quality.

I feel like such an adult now buying 2 sets of these for making cookies. I loved that the silicone mats are in my favorite color, the color I use for allll my kitchen stuff. However, I did not love the mats. First batch came out sad. So I tried making another batch and cooked 6 with the mat, 6 with parchment paper... parchment paper was the winner, hands down. Silicone mat cookies didn't spread out enough, even though I like my cookies puffy it was too much. The taste was kind of flour-y, didn't know a mat could make that much of a difference. The bottoms, I like just a little bit of crispness, but there wasn't any. I used to use cheap nonstick pans with parchment paper. I'm now using these pans with parchment paper, and it's really not much different. Except these are pretty and shiny and make me feel like a grown up. I like the racks, I didn't have racks at all before. They're worth getting. But I'd skip the mats, as cute as they are. They just don't make for good sickerdoodles.